23. November 2022

Very strong legal position of pension funds regarding the planned winding-up of ÍL-sjóður

The Minister of Finance's planned legislation on the bankruptcy or comparable debt settlement of ÍL-sjóður is contrary to the Constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights. This is among the substantive conclusions of a legal opinion from LOGOS, prepared for the Icelandic pension funds and presented at their meeting earlier today. The LOGOS opinion states that such intervention would amount to expropriation or another form of curtailment of property rights contrary to the Constitution, and would create a liability for the Icelandic state to compensate bondholders.

The legal opinion further states that the Minister of Finance bears direct responsibility for ÍL-sjóður's obligations following the changes made to the Housing Financing Fund by the 2019 legislative amendment. The LOGOS opinion notes that ÍL-sjóður came into being when the Housing Financing Fund was split up by law in 2019, which placed the Minister of Finance in overall charge of the fund. Following the change, ÍL-sjóður became part of the responsibilities of the Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs, which is responsible for the fund's day-to-day management. ÍL-sjóður is thus not a subordinate agency of the Minister, given that the Minister of Finance holds administrative and operational authority over the fund. ÍL-sjóður is therefore not considered a separate subordinate agency, but rather part of the Ministry. Accordingly, the Icelandic state is a debtor rather than merely a guarantor. This is also consistent with the plan to move the fund under the A-section of the central government accounts from the turn of the year. On this basis, the Minister of Finance bears direct responsibility for the fund and its obligations, in LOGOS's opinion.

The opinion further states that, should the Minister of Finance decide to wind up the fund with the result that claims against the bankruptcy estate fall due, the Icelandic state would unequivocally bear responsibility for current and future obligations under the terms of the bonds, together with default interest.

The LOGOS legal opinion is extensive and underlines the very strong position of Icelandic pension funds in view of the Minister of Finance's stated aims regarding changes to ÍL-sjóður, which, under current circumstances, would likely result in tens of billions of krónur in losses for the public in the form of reduced pension rights.

LOGOS legal opinion

LOGOS presentation

Back to news