21. November 2023
The bill is a recipe for prolonged litigation
The finance minister's bill on the winding-up of the ÍL Fund entails recognition of bondholders' right to interest on housing bonds all the way to final maturity, and of the state's guarantee of those bonds. This represents a fundamental change in the minister's position compared with previously. However, the bill would fall far short of achieving its stated objectives if it became law. It would most likely increase state expenditure, disrupt the balance of the financial market, create decades of uncertainty regarding the settlement of the ÍL Fund's obligations, and damage the state's reputation. The legislation would therefore directly undermine the very objectives it aims to achieve. It also appears that no appropriate analysis has been carried out by the ministry or the Central Bank regarding financial stability, the money supply and, consequently, inflation and other such factors.
This is stated in detailed comments submitted today by the law firm LOGOS, on behalf of twenty pension funds, to the government's consultation portal regarding the bill.
The comments further state that the bill clearly indicates that the Icelandic state intends to sidestep its guarantee obligations towards bondholders, despite outwardly recognising them. The legislation would amount to expropriation, or a compensable restriction of bondholders' property rights, without satisfying the requirements of the constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights regarding the quality of legislation, public need, full compensation and proportionality.
The bill is a recipe for prolonged legal disputes between the Icelandic state and the country's pension funds before the courts.
Numerous other comments are made on the draft bill, including on economic aspects prepared in consultation with Dr. Hersir Sigurgeirsson, Professor of Finance at the University of Iceland, and Arctica Finance. LOGOS's comments are included, along with an overview of the main points.
Summary of comments on the draft bill
Submission on the draft bill