9. April 2010

Pension funds draw lessons from the collapse

A committee, appointed by the National Association of Pension Funds in May 2009 to consider what “lessons pension funds could learn from the financial shocks that have hit Icelandic society, all the way from the collapse of the three commercial banks in early October 2008”, proposes changes to business practices in the securities market, to the regulatory framework, and to the pension funds' operating environment. The committee presented its report, Lessons of the Pension Funds from the Collapse 2008–2009, to 80–90 pension fund representatives at a meeting at the Grand Hótel in Reykjavík on 8 April.

The committee believes that pension funds should impose stricter requirements on securities issuers, brokers, the stock exchange and asset managers, and safeguard their interests more actively and in a more varied manner from now on than before, including by:

  • tightening the terms of securities and financial instruments to protect pension funds' rights and position when purchases take place.
  • pressing for the immediate listing of securities and increased disclosure on the stock exchange regarding issuers, the volume of transactions and their nature.
  • promoting improved corporate governance in companies and safeguarding the interests of small shareholders.

The report states, among other things, in the chapter on equities, page 5:
“It appears that the price formation of shares in many companies was directed by the largest participants through the excessive use of borrowed capital and holding companies in the hands of related or affiliated parties. Disclosure of ownership and of the financing of large shareholders was seriously lacking, and it was therefore impossible for participants such as pension funds to grasp the extent of these ownership links or the risk of a chain-reaction collapse.”

The committee proposes that, following foreign practice, a creditors' representative (bondholder agent) be appointed for each bond issue to safeguard their interests, and that the register of companies should always clearly show who the largest shareholders in companies are and how they may be connected, where the combined holdings of these shareholders exceed 5%.

It may also be noted that the committee recommends that pension funds take a more active part in debate and criticism, both publicly and at annual general meetings and shareholder meetings.

It is proposed that pension funds increase their cooperation and joint initiative within the National Association of Pension Funds in order to press for improvements in other areas of the financial market and the economy, and to present Alþingi, the ministries, supervisory authorities and the stock exchange with their proposals for improvements, based partly on successful business practices abroad.

The “Lessons Committee” was made up of Stefán Halldórsson, former CEO of the Pension Fund of Engineers, Chairman; Baldur Vilhjálmsson, Head of Asset Management at the Pension Fund of State Employees; Helga Indriðadóttir, fund manager at Almenni Pension Fund; Ólafur Sigurðsson, CEO of Stafir Pension Fund; and Tryggvi Tryggvason, Head of Asset Management at Gildi Pension Fund. Working alongside them was Hrafn Magnússon, CEO of the National Association of Pension Funds.

Further information is available from Stefán Halldórsson, tel. 897 0333, email address shall@centrum.is

The report can be accessed here.

You will need Adobe Reader to open the report. If you do not have it, you can get it here.

here

Back to news